At first it was kind of hard to keep on reading but as I gave it another try, I couldn’t put it down. It follows ten years but it doesn’t feel rushed and gives good plots ro each of the characters. I wish that Jack would’ve gotten more “screen time” but it was perfect just like the ending.

Love the establishment of relationships, that leads to really understanding each characters feelings. Loved that the narrative is from different perspectives. Wished there was more perspective of Sarah. But overall, super satisfied and a new Josie Silver fan.

Loved the story. And I loved how there are such strong characters in this book.

A very sweet story of love and friendship. The only thing it took too long to get to the end and then that’s it… but a very refreshing, romantic story

Great Christmas time romance. Had me tempted to blow through and binge the whole thing but this was something to savor. Great one

The back of the book made it sound great & the overall idea was good. But it was very slow & hard to keep interest

So good! I feel like the ending was a little rushed tho. But I loved it.

I guess every time when I think of Edinburg the first thing that pops into my mind will be their kissing.

Great characters .. only wish the story itself read with a little more speed

For me, it took a very long time to get to the part that gives you chills. Only happened in the last 40 pages or so for me. The rest of the story was just a bit dull and me hoping that any time they’d have some huge lovers quarrel or at least something.